What happens if I bring the black star to Nelacar?

If you bring it to Azura, you will be able to use it to trap any sized soul except for black souls (i.e., souls from NPCs). If you bring it to Nelacar, you will be able to trap all souls, including black, though Nelacar tells you that it can only trap black souls (see bugs section).

Which is better the black star or Azuras star?

Black is better if you don’t care about roleplaying. It allows you to use human souls vs the soul of anything else from Azura’s. I Totally Agree. The Black Star is Better as Black/Human Souls are More Powerful than Normal “White Souls” Such as Animals etc..

Who should I give the black star to?

Nelacar
For the Black Star, a refillable black soul gem, take the star to Nelacar, where he will place the Dragonborn inside the star where Malyn will have to be defeated. Upon Malyn’s defeat, Nelacar will pull the Dragonborn out of the star and gift the newly made Black Star as a reward.

How do you get the black star and Azura star?

To receive this quest, the Dragonborn must first talk with Aranea Ienith at the Shrine of Azura, south of Winterhold. She will say that Azura has chosen the Dragonborn as her champion, and that they must find “an elven mage who can turn the brightest star to the darkest night.”

What is the best thing to do with Azura’s Star?

Like regular soul gems, Azura’s Star has the ability to trap white souls, or those of creatures. These souls can be used for enchanting or recharging. Followers wielding weapons with Soul Trap can use Azura’s Star to capture souls.

Are black souls better than grand?

All black souls are of the grand level. The main benefit of a black soul gem is that it can capture grand leveled souls from humanoids, whereas those souls cannot normally be captured. These sources tend to be plentiful and easier to kill, compared with common grand level white soul sources, such as mammoths.